Decision Delayed On Possible Road Closure

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers representative Chris Bearden (left) and attorney John Crow review the map showing Burchfield Road.
By David Howell
Editor
BOAT LANDING – A decision to close a county road that accesses Corps property near the Water Valley Boat Landing was delayed to allow more input for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers following a public hearing on Jan. 22.
The hearing was scheduled after Lacy Whitaker asked supervisors for relief during a December meeting, specifically requesting that a 50-yard stretch of Burchfield Road that runs through her property be closed. The entire length of Burchfield Road is almost a tenth of a mile long, running off of County Road 53 and ending just past Whitaker’s property line on Corps property. The road also serves as access to a hayfield owned by the Corps which is leased out.
Whitaker explained the traffic had become problematic, and problems include damage to her property and one hunter even threatening to shoot toward her house after she asked him not to hunt on her property line.
The road is located in District 3, and Supervisor Lee McMinn described the sentiment from both sides during the hearing before asking for more input from the Corps. McMinn represents District 3.
“There is no one here from the other side but that does not mean that they aren’t concerned about it or very passionate about their position,” McMinn explained, adding he had talked to almost a dozen people that have been using the road to access the Corps land for recreational purposes.
“I have a complete appreciation for both sides,” McMinn added.
He also said he talked to the individual that Whitaker had the confrontation with.
“What she said happened, it happened,” McMinn said.
McMinn added that responsible, avid outdoorsmen had used the road to access the lake for fishing or hunting for years with no problems and it would be difficult to access the Corps property in that area from other public entrances.
“I would hate to see those people that have been using it for decades cut off because one or two people have acted up and caused a hardship for the people that live on that road,” McMinn continued before turning to U.S. Corps representative Chris Bearden for input.
Bearden described two options the Corps would have if the county closes the road – abandoning the hayfield and planting trees on the open ground or making another access road to the hayfield.
Bearden also answered questions from McMinn about a sign already placed at the entrance of the hayfield prohibiting motorized vehicles, explaining the sign limits vehicles, but explained that the Corps does not restrict ATV traffic in most areas.
“I feel like that is coming one day,” Bearden added, referring to ATV traffic.
Later in the meeting, McMinn asked for a commitment from the Corps about making another road to access the Corps property.
“I really can’t answer that, it would be an option would be on the table,” Bearden answered. “People want to make trails through the woods, they do that anyway. Nobody is going to scold them for opening up those old field roads,” Bearden added.
“But I will pass that on,” Bearden added, about McMinn’s request to create an alternate access road that would bypass Whitaker’s property.
Whitaker also addressed supervisors as the hearing came to a close.
“I want to second the request to put another access out there. We love the lake bottom and we are not trying to prevent anybody from enjoying the lake,” Whitaker told supervisors. But she repeated the problems from lake goers traveling through the current road, including people driving too fast, warranted the current road be closed.
