County Declines To Sell Building

Oakland school building
By David Howell
Editor
COFFEEVILLE – An eight year quest by Melvin Gary to purchase a dilapidated school building in Oakland came to an end July 17 when supervisors agreed not to sell or lease the building or property. The decision followed a closed door session during a meeting held July 16 at the Coffeeville courthouse when supervisors discussed the potential real estate transaction.
Mississippi’s Open Meetings Act cites prospective purchases, sale or lease of lands as one of 11 reasons a public body can enter executive session.
“I think that it is the board’s opinion at this time that we are not going to sell it or act on it in any fashion,” Board President Tommy Vaughn told Gary following the discussion in executive session. Vaughn cited the $35,000 appraised value for the 12 acres and building as low, explaining that to keep the property may prove more valuable long-term.
Gary, a candidate for District 4 Supervisor, then countered, questioning whether the appraisal included the building and 12 acres or just the value of the building, citing earlier confusion about the appraisal.
“I was interested in the building. I have accepted that price for the building,” Gary said about the $35,000 value,” Gary said, adding that he would only need to lease additional acreage to park adjacent to the building.
“Our discussion was pretty much, we feel like the potential long-term benefit for the county in holding on to the property might be greater than a sale now,” District 3 Supervisor Lee McMinn reiterated. “We think down the road there might be an opportunity to do something else with the whole property and we don’t want to jeopardize that by breaking it up.”
“Was leasing it taken off the table?” Gary asked.
“Yes,” Vaughn answered.
“Because of the asbestos issue,” Board Attorney John Crow added.
Gary explained he had talked with an official with the Mississippi Department of Environmental Quality before Friday’s meeting, who explained the asbestos may not pose any health threat if left undisturbed.
“He gave me all the particulars, in terms of health risks,” Gary explained. “He said the county would not be liable in any condition.”
“The decision has already been made. We are going to abide by it… At this point in time we feel like the value is worth more to the county to keep it,” Vaughn said.
Next Gary asked about recent thefts at the building.
“Is that a concern to you guys?” Gary asked.
“Absolutely, we are aware of it,” Vaughn answered.
Gary also questioned $5,000 spent by the county for an asbestos inspection and appraisal.
“I suppose the question that really just boggles my mind is that in excess of $5,000 has been paid for an appraisal and there seems there was never really been any serious consideration unless the $35,000 it was appraised for was the thing that caused you to back up and change your mind. The taxpayers hard-earned money has already been paid for the inspection and for the appraisal,” Gary said.
“I disagree with you,” Vaughn said, citing the deliberations about the potential sale of the building. Vaughn also said the decision was ultimately made to protect the taxpayers because all five supervisors agreed it would benefit the county to keep the property.
“I realize the time and effort you put into it. I know it has got to be a let down. But it was a unanimous decision,” Vaughn said.
History of the Project
Gary first approached supervisors in 2007 about a potential lease or lease-purchase on the building to operate a non-profit center for on-the-job training facility for at-risk, unemployed people in the area. The issue resurfaced in 2013 when Gary came back to supervisors with the same question, citing sporadic use of the facility by the West Yalobusha Community Action Agency, the entity leasing the building.
Gary’s 2013 visit brought the status of the county’s lease with West Yalobusha Community Action Agency into question and county officials determined the lease expired in 2008.
In early 2014, supervisors voted to execute a new, five-year lease with Lizzie Earl and West Yalobusha Community Action Agency after letting District 4 Supervisor George Suggs make the recommendation on whether to lease the building to Earl or to Gary’s organization, “We The People.” The property is located in Suggs’ district and is also adjacent to his county barn.
Earl told supervisors the kids play ball in the school gym and the facility is also used for family reunions and other gatherings.
Last December Gary told supervisors the building likely contained asbestos and may be a hazard. Gary also told supervisors that his group was prepared to make an offer on purchasing the building, but he noted the asbestos would significantly lower the value.
Citing the potential danger of asbestos, supervisors then terminated the lease with Earl and the building is currently vacant. Super-visors also ordered an asbestos inspection, which confirmed portions of the building contained asbestos. The appraisal was ordered after Gary said he would purchase the building.
