Skip to content

Mystery Badge Creates Questions

This Yalobusha County badge is at least a century old and has several indentions that could have been made by birdshot.

Mystery Badge Creates Questions


By David Howell

Editor


CALIFORNIA – A century-old Yalobusha County sheriff’s badge that turned up in Claremont, Calif., last year has a retired law enforcement officer and badge collector curious about the badge’s history. Jack Bushey has a passion for collecting old law enforcement badges and has a large collection, which he maintains in his personal museum in California. Bushey is interested in finding the history of the Yalobusha County badge, which could have been worn by multiple deputies during its span of duty.


What sparked his curiosity is several distinct indentions that could have been made by birdshot pellets.


“It appears plausible that someone was wearing this badge when struck with a blast of birdshot,” Bushey told the Herald.


Bushey has a lengthy law enforcement background, retiring as Deputy Chief of the San Bernardino Sheriff’s Department and as Commander of the Los Angeles Police Department. Currently he works as a member of Senior Faculty of the FBI Law Enforcement Executive Development Association.


The badge mystery is his personal project and he is looking for input from Herald readers with hopes to learn more about this piece of the county’s law enforcement history.


Was a deputy wearing the badge when it was hit with pellets?


What kind of call was he answering?


And even more challenging, how did the badge end up in California?


Bushey knows the badge was made by a New York company, Tower and Lyon Company. That company made badges from 1884 to 1916, which dates the piece back at least a century.  Based on indentions on the badge, Bushey is guessing the impact was a relatively low velocity of birdshot with minimum penetration.


“The wounds would most likely have been painful, but not serious,” Bushey calculated.


Historian Jack Gurner recalled one incident that was included in a Herald’s Looking Back article last year that possibly could be linked to the badge. 


In 1964, four Yalobusha County men, a pair of brothers, along with J.H. Langham and Ray Hylander, were being held on open charges after they were involved in a shooting incident during which deputy sheriff Lloyd Hughes and landowner Tal Brower were wounded. The four men were “joyriding” on a bulldozer being used in road construction. The men drove the dozer into Brower’s pasture and when approached by Hughes and Brower, Hylander fired a blast from a 12-gauge shotgun. Doctors removed 43 birdshot from Hughes and 38 from Brower.


This incident could be one explanation on the badge’s history, but that would mean the badge would have been in use for at least 50 years.

Former sheriff Lloyd Defer recalls Hughes wearing a similar, silver badge in that era.


“When I met him in 1970 he was wearing a silver badge,” former Yalobusha County Sheriff Lloyd Defer told the Herald. “I can remember, him driving a 1970 model Plymouth patrol car.”


If this is the badge worn by Hughes during the 1964 shooting, that means it would have been in use at least 50 years as the company stopped production in 1916. The 1964 incident is just one theory about the possible origin of the birdshot-riddled badge and the Herald welcomes input. 


“I would like to create a ‘stand alone’ that shows the badge, possibly a photo of the person who wore it when shot if ever determined and a plaque describing what occurred,” Bushey told the Herald.


Anyone with possible information on the badge can contact the Herald officer at (662) 473-1473 or email David Howell at  dhowl@bellsouth.net.

1 Comments

  1. Michelle Doole on October 15, 2019 at 1:42 pm

    Lloyd Hughes was my grandfather. It is very likely this could have been his badge. I am planning on showing this article to my father to verify and will send confirmation as soon as possible.

Leave a Comment