Historic Jail Added To Endangered List
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
An empty chair catches the morning light inside the Old Yalobusha County Jail, a haunting reminder of the building’s past. The 120-year-old landmark was recently listed among Mississippi’s 10 Most Endangered Historic Places.
– File Photo by Jack Gurner
WATER VALLEY – The Old Yalobusha County Jail, a 120-year-old landmark standing beside the courthouse in Water Valley, has been named to Mississippi’s 10 Most Endangered Historic Places list for 2025.
The recognition was announced Thursday night in Jackson during a Mississippi Heritage Trust ceremony unveiling the 15th edition of the statewide list, which highlights historic structures at risk and in need of preservation support. The Water Valley landmark is among just 150 sites that have earned the designation since the program began in 1999.
“This designation is really a starting point to rally support behind a place that’s meaningful,” said Lolly Rash, executive director of the Mississippi Heritage Trust. “It’s about bringing people together to ask how we can find the resources to make this happen. When everyone agrees that a place matters, that’s when progress begins.”
The nomination for the jail came from Chris Goodwin, director of the Water Valley Main Street Association, who said the recognition offers both validation and opportunity for a building that has long captured the city’s imagination. “The Old Yalobusha County Jail is one of the most significant structures in the city,” Goodwin said. “It and its next-door neighbor, the courthouse, tell the story of how people here interacted with the legal system through records of births and deaths, marriages and divorces, property transactions, trials, and even executions.”
The Old Yalobusha County Jail, built in 1904, is now listed among Mississippi’s most endangered historic places. The jail is on Blackmur Drive.
Goodwin said the Main Street Association hopes to work with the Heritage Trust and other partners to secure funding for restoration and to identify a new use for the structure. “When we drive on Blackmur we see the worst of the building, but things aren’t as dire as they look,” he said. “The Mississippi Heritage Trust has a long history of helping endangered sites find a path to practical use, and they really put their weight behind the projects they identify as particularly significant, like this one. We’ll work with them to identify grants opportunities, tax credits, and other funding sources.”
Built in 1904 by the Pauly Jail Building Company of St. Louis, the two-story brick structure once housed the sheriff’s department on the first floor and prisoners upstairs. The upper level features two prefabricated “kit jails,” each with six or more steel-riveted cells. The Pauly family, who began as steamboat blacksmiths on the Mississippi River, set the national standard for jail construction in the early 1900s and remain in operation today. While a number of their “kit jails” were once installed around the country, few, if any, survive intact.
In the nomination, it was cited that the Water Valley jail is essentially untouched from its original form, a time capsule complete with metal floors and ceilings, small meal pass-throughs, a dumbwaiter used to lift food from the kitchen below, and the trapdoor used for hangings. The steel ring that once held the rope still hangs from the ceiling.
Further information in the nomination included the building’s history featuring civic milestones and darker moments. In 1931, two men convicted of a grisly double murder were executed there, drawing national attention. In 1958, the fatal beating of Woodrow Wilson Daniels, a Black man, by white sheriff James G. Treloar, became an early civil rights-era case.
The jail remained in service until 1964, when a new facility opened on Calhoun Street. It was later used for office and storage space before closing in 2011 due to safety concerns. A 2023 engineering report by Mark Watson of Tupelo found deterioration in the outer brick walls and metal ties but no structural issues with the foundation, concluding that the building remains stable for now.
Rash said that kind of stability gives preservation efforts a real chance. “The great thing about the Water Valley project is that there’s already local support and energy behind it,” she said. “When communities come together around a place like this, amazing things can happen.”
The Old Yalobusha County Jail is designated a Mississippi Landmark, the state’s highest level of historic recognition. The status protects it from inappropriate alterations while making it eligible for preservation grants and incentives. Goodwin said the next step is building momentum. “This recognition gives us the foundation to start moving forward.”
Water Valley Main Street Association Director Chris Goodwin points to a painting of the Old Yalobusha County Jail, a 1904 landmark recently recognized among Mississippi’s most endangered places. Goodwin nominated the building for the recognition.
