Skip to content

Property Owner Questions Tax Bill

Kagan Coughlin showed receipts that work continued during much of 2015 and after the property was assessed. Coughlin explained much of the building was not ready for renters because of the ongoing work.

By David Howell

Editor

WATER VALLEY – A property owner may get a reprieve on his 2015 property taxes after he explained to county supervisors that his renovation was not complete when it was assessed in January. Speaking at the “first Monday” supervisor meeting in Water Valley, historic preservation enthusiast Kagan Coughlin explained that work on the four buildings that compose Blu-Buck Mercantile on Main Street was not totally complete until October.

Coughlin’s appearance followed the recent mailing of the 2015 tax bills, which are due January 30, and calculated based on the assessed value of the property on January 1, 2015.  Coughlin explained that only 18 percent of the total square feet of Blu-Buck Mercantile was rented in January 1. Speaking after the meeting, Coughlin said the city and county taxes increased from $1,154.28 to $9,265.71.

“I want to start by saying I believe in paying property taxes,” Couglin told the board, adding the he has invested in several properties since moving to Water Valley nine years ago. 

“I love this town, I love this county and we have put every nickel we have into it,” he told the board.

Tax assessor/collector Linda Shuffield cited multiple sources used to determine the buildings were habitable, including ads placed by Coughlin seeking to rent apartment space in late 2014 and the open house in February that allowed visitors to tour the span of buildings. She also explained the buildings had no value prior to the renovation, and the earlier tax bill only included the assessed value of the lots.

Coughlin explained that upstairs work on the apartments was completed first, with the first apartment rented in October, 2014, and a second upstairs apartment rented in January. Coughlin said worked continued on the other upstairs apartments and commercial space downstairs in 2015. Coughlin also said he purposely scheduled the open house prior to the project being fully completed to allow access to the buildings before they were rented. He also said plumbing and heating and cooling work remained after the open house before he could start renting the spaces. 

“Does a vacant building have not value?” Shuffield questioned, referring to the fact that the assessment in January came as the majority of Couglin’s work on the buildings had been completed on January 1, even if they were not rented.

The matter is scheduled to be revisited during a recessed meeting on Dec. 21. Shuffield said that the assessment could be reduced by 50 percent on the buildings, if it is the will of the Board of Supervisors, based on evidence presented by Coughlin that work was ongoing after the property was assessed for the 2015 taxes.

The veteran tax assessor also explained that the property is unique because the buildings span four lots but is considered one assessment.

“It’s hard to divide,” Shuffield explained, as the upstairs apartments span multiple buildings.

 Coughlin also questioned the assessed value of the buildings, taxes that will be levied on the buildings in the coming years, based on the assessed value. He presented supervisors a cost analysis he presented to the bank to obtain a loan when he purchased the property in late 2013. Coughlin explained that part of that documentation was estimating the cash flow including the cost of property taxes, and he used the tax bill on the B.T.C. building as a comparison.

“The Blu-Buck buildings are a little less that twice the size of the B.T.C. building, and the tax bill is four times what the B.T.C. building is,” Coughlin explained about the assessment. “At that tax rate, you cannot charge enough rent in Water Valley, Mississippi, to pay those bills.”

“We have very little control over the tax assessment,” Board President Tommy Vaughn explained during the 20 minutes discussion on the matter.

“The Department of Revenue gives the guidelines that we appraise by, square foot cost and the application,” Shuffield added.

The topic also sparked a brief conversation about the county’s tax base after Vaughn noted the county has an aging population.

“When you have a school district with a D rating, it’s extremely hard to get young people to move into our county and bring their kids to go to school and that’s your tax base,” Vaughn said. We are at 56 percent of the people in Yalobusha County that don’t pay full or any taxes or all. If we are ever going to get this tax rate down, we are going to have to work on our school system.”

Coughlin noted the downtown renovation is a driving force for attracting young people to move to the county.

“The work that we do in our downtown can attract younger people,” Coughlin explained, adding that all four of his upstairs Blu-Buck building apartments are occupied by young couples who moved to town.

Leave a Comment