Judge Candidates Spar At Weekend Political Rally

Judicial candidates for District 2 Justice Court Judge (from left) Trent Howell, Larry Lawler and incumbent Steve Riley were hot on the trail campaigning at last Saturday’s political rally in Coffeeville. – Photos by Mark Anthony
Staff Report
COFFEEVILLE – Yalobusha candidates were back at it last Saturday, as political hopefuls lined up to speak at a political rally sponsored by the Coffeeville Saddle Club and Yalobusha 4-H Club.
Despite the hot weather, many candidates turned out including three running for District Two Justice Court Judge.
Water Valley attorney Trent Howell was first to speak. Howell is running as an independent and will face the winner of the August Democratic Primary election between incumbent Steve Riley and the Larry Lawler, in the November General Election.
Howell began his speech, explaining his experience serving 17 years as municipal judge for the City of Water Valley.
Howell then pointed to a correlation between the cases he presides over in municipal court to cases in justice court.
“That gives me a benefit from that experience,” Howell added.
Howell also explained why he was running as an independent.
“I feel that all judge elections should be non-partisan. Every other judge’s race is non-partisan. I feel justice court judge elections should be the same way… In my view, there is no place for politics in the courtroom.”
Howell then shifted to the reason he is running for judge.
“The question I am often asked as I campaign is, ‘Why do you want to be a justice court judge?’” Howell explained.
“The past 31 years I have practiced law in virtually every state court that we have. I have seen more errors, more mistakes more injustices in the justice court than any court that I have practiced in. The reason, in view, is because justice court judges are not required to have legal education. Because more cases are coming before justice court judges and because those cases are increasingly complex, I believe we need a judge who studies the law everyday, not just on a part-time basis,” Howell said.
“For the most part our Mississippi justice court judges are good, well-meaning, honest people. Those in our county certainly are and I would be the first to say that. But often times they are simply not able to cope with the volume and complexity of cases that come before them. The result is often bad decisions,” Howell added.
“For many people, the only place they have in the Mississippi Judicial System is justice court. They get a raw deal, they don’t find justice, then that’s it for them. They have no recourse. It costs money to appeal to a higher court. Many people simply don’t have the money it costs to appeal from a bad decision,” Howell added.
“Being a justice court judge in Mississippi today is serious business. Times are different now from when this system was established,” Howell said.
“I have the most training, the most experience, I have the research capabilities. The main thing I have is the desire to be a good justice court judge,” Howell added.
“If elected I promise to be fair, treat all with respect, to work hard and to render the proper decision,” Howell concluded.
Lawler
Next to take the podium was Lawler.
Lawler told the crowd that he and his wife had been active land owners since 1974 and moved to the county permanently in 1994.
Lawler recounted his work experience including formerly owning and operating Lawler’s Grocery in the Sylva Rena community.
“I have an associates degree in engineering. I have served you all as a volunteer fire fighter with Sylva Rena Fire Department for the last 15 years and I am a deacon at Sylva Rena Baptist Church,” Lawler said.
Lawler also said he had 25 years experience in human relations, contract administration, grievance and arbitration settlement.
“This work perfectly parallels the duties of the justice court judge. I feel very, very comfortable with my abilities to apply testimony to the law and develop a sound judgement.”
Lawler then provided three commitments if elected judge.
“First I will not forget that I work for the citizens of Yalobusha County. I will never assume that the justice court system belongs to me personally. Secondly, I will have no rule for your courtroom that alienates or otherwise makes our law enforcement officers feel uncomfortable about appearing in court to testify. Third, if you ever appear before me in court you will be treated with respect and dignity. You will receive a fair and unbiased hearing, based on the testimony that you present and based on Mississippi law tempered with common sense,” Lawler said.
He then countered Howell’s comments about the benefits of electing an attorney for the job.
“The Mississippi State Constitution spells out the requirements to be a justice court judge. To be a Chancery Court Judge and a Circuit Court Judge, you must have a law degree,” Lawler explained.
Justice court is essential an entry level court, Lawler explained, and said the state constitution only requires a high school diploma to serve as judge.
“Between the time you are elected and the time you are sworn in, you have to go for some very intense training,” Lawler continued.
“There really is nothing complicated about the justice court system. The jurisdiction of justice court has not changed significantly in the last 16 to 18 years. And neither has the qualifications to be a justice court judge,” Lawler added.
Riley
Incumbent Steve Riley followed, and first explained that although he is elected on the Water Valley side of the county, he serves people all over the county.
“Ladies and gentlemen, I use common sense in my court. I sure do. But if you don’t go by them blue books called the Mississippi Code, you are not going to be there long. You sure won’t be,” Riley said.
“Mr. Lawler is a friend of mine and Mr. Howell is a former football player with me and was a year ahead of me in school, we have been friends forever. But don’t let him bull you because ladies and gentlemen, he is upset over losing cases. We ruled on the evidence. The evidence presented in court,” Riley countered.
Riley then shifted to his experience, telling the crowd he has presided over 50,000 civil and criminal cases in the last 31 and half years.
“Mr. Lawler made reference of making up rules,” Riley said. Reaching into his bag, he picked up a law book.
“I don’t alienate law enforcement officers. We have rules to go by. It is a rule in Chancery Court that no person other than law enforcement officers shall take or carry a firearm or weapon into the courtroom. When a law enforcement officer takes the stand as litigants or witnesses, they shall be required to remove their firearm,” Riley added.
“That’s the rules of their court. Chancery Court has rules, you won’t see them in the Supreme Court carrying weapons,” Riley noted.
“In the Justice Court we have rules made up by the Mississippi Supreme Court. And if you don’t go by the rules of justice court, you are going to be in trouble. Judicial Performance is going to come get you. They are going to remove you from office before the voters can get you at the next election,” Riley continued.
“Rule 1.02 of the justice court laws in the second paragraph states: ‘No one shall bear a firearm of any description in the courthouse room unless the bailiff or necessary guard for the prisoners unless authorized by the court.’” Riley added.
“When officers are there most of the time, they are there as witnesses just like a defendant is. They are not there for courtroom security, they are not the bailiff,” Riley continued.
“The most stressful place in the courtroom is the witness stand. You take your state troopers, your deputy sheriffs, they are carrying a taser, they got a leg gun on their leg. When they get in that witness chair we have them take the weapon out of the holster and remove their weapon at that time. That is the only point in time their weapon is taken from them. They are sitting there with two weapons.
“Mr. Lawler has been going door-to-door talking about me. And that’s good. He thinks I made this rule and it’s a rule by the Mississippi Supreme Court,” Riley added.
“Let’s take one more example. If everybody is toting a gun in the courtroom and we got this rule and the last thing it says ‘unless authorized by the court.’ If someone gets mad in the courtroom and jumps up and starts fighting and the officer jumps up and pulls his weapon and shoots somebody, I am the one civilly and criminally liable for that because I allowed them to tote their weapon.
“I am going to let the law enforcement officers of the State of Mississippi carry their weapons in the courtroom. But when they get on the witness stand, they are not going to have that weapon that they can easily access when thing get tough on them,” Riley said.
The incumbent judge concluded his speech stressing his experience.
“I have got all the training. Come December, if you elect a new judge you have to go off for 32 hours training. Then they got to take an examination. If they don’t pass the examination, they got another 24 hour class to go through. If they don’t pass that, come August 1 the Board of Supervisors will remove them from office. You have to call another election… I don’t have to take the test, but if I took the test I could pass it. I’m sure they probably can too. Friends, I am running on my record as Justice Court Judge. For 31 and half years, I have never been late for court. We have started court on time and I have not been absent,” Riley closed.
